Open neutrals have long
been an annoyance for utilities resulting in many claims for damages
incurred by sensitive electronic equipment. Throughout the years this
problem has started to snowball.
The three examples
below are some of the major causes of open neutrals. Each is further
identified by conditions that contribute to the situation:
1. Equipment
malfunction
- Connector failure
- Transformer malfunction
- Environmental condition equipment
failures
2. Natural causes
- Weather induced failure
-
Hurricanes
-
Tornadoes
-
Rain
-
Ice storms
-
Flooding
-
Lightning
3. Human error
- Improper installation
- Poor quality of splice
- Improper connector for job
- Improper drop considerations /
installations
- Accidental line contacts
Although there are
other causes, they are fairly isolated and less common.
The
mechanics
In the secondary of a
properly grounded "T" wound transformer, load has little
effect on the voltage other than the occasional flicker caused by
switching large load, which is considered normal operation. However, if
we disconnect the center tap of the secondary, which references ground,
then we allow the mid point to "drift" from side to side and
it becomes directly affected by load. This floating connection takes on
two forms, one is high impedance (open) the other is low impedance
(partial). The later example is considered the worst case, because it
can vary dramatically so much from one second to another and can be
difficult to locate. The first hint of a problem usually gets to the
utility as a customer report (i.e. "my back bedroom lights are
bright white and the living room lights are a pale orange"). To a
light bulb this may do little or nothing but to a big screen TV it could
mean it’s end of operational life.
Another red flag
regarding open neutrals is extreme equipment failure or mis-operation.
As an example of Surge Protective Device (SPD) are extremely sensitive
to open neutral conditions and can fail catastrophically. SPDs are
designed to deal with momentary transient surges and not extended
overvoltage conditions. A transient surge is a sub cycle anomaly while
swells can last for a few cycles or more. Open neutrals can
theoretically last until fixed.
The
SPD problem
Sustained overvoltage
conditions are usually fatal to (MOV/SAD) based SPDs. The mentioned
above conditions have resulted in changes UL’s UL1449 standard,
which requires thermal disconnect capabilities.
We at Meter-Treater
have always provided our customers with the safest products we could
take in consideration applicable standards and application scenarios.
To this end we have maintained an aggressive R&D program to come
up with a coordinated fusing element capable of delivering both a
thermal disconnect and high current capabilities. The result of a
fusing mechanism that can survive high surge current without
degradation of normally associated with micro-disconnect devices. Also
required a device which could provide high symmetrical fault
capability yet disconnect under short circuit conditions. As a result
of our R&D program all products shipped from Meter-Treater, Inc.
are equipped with fuse devices fulfilling all the above requirements.
Special
considerations
Currently the best
method for locating an open neutral involves listening to your
customer, and careful site inspections. There are test devices which
introduce current imbalances and create one leg loading to create the
voltage swings common with open neutrals. We should also comment that
if an open neutral exists, and the device described above is employed,
damage to SPD could result, so disconnecting the SPD is recommended.
There really isn’t a
solution, but open neutrals will exist as long as people run multiple
voltages in the home. All we can do to reduce the problem of open
neutrals is to be alert and make proper decisions with regards to
installation and application of electrical equipment in today’s
electrical facilities.
|